Welcome to Paisanos Pizza (New City)
At Paisanos Pizza in New City, our passion for pizza drives us to create unforgettable culinary experiences. Located at 730 NY-304, we serve a diverse menu encompassing delicious square Sicilian pizzas, flavorful wraps, and scrumptious soups. Our signature dishes, like the Paisano Special pizza with robust toppings and the praised garlic knots, showcase our commitment to quality. Patrons appreciate our inviting atmosphere and attentive service, complemented by unique creations like the SCAR wrap and inventive sliders. With a focus on fresh ingredients and customer satisfaction, Paisanos Pizza is more than a meal; it’s a cherished community gathering spot.
- 730 NY-304, New City, NY 10956, United States Hotline: +1 845-709-6234
Welcome to Paisanos Pizza (New City)
If you're in New City and searching for a slice of heaven, look no further than Paisanos Pizza. Nestled conveniently at 730 NY-304, this vibrant pizzeria offers a blend of traditional and innovative flavors that will delight your taste buds. With a dedication to quality that shines through in every dish, it's no wonder diners rave about their experiences.
Menu Highlights
The menu at Paisanos is a treasure trove for pizza lovers and food enthusiasts alike:
- Square Sicilian Pizza: A crowd favorite, with options like the classic Plain Square Sicilian ($25.16) and the flavorful Vegetable Special Square Sicilian ($28.59).
- Delicious Wraps: Perfect for a quick lunch, the wraps include enticing selections such as the Grilled Chicken Wrap and the Bacon & Ranch Wrap ($13.72 each).
- Hearty Soups: Warm up with any of their delightful soups, each priced at $8.01, including Chicken Noodle and Minestrone.
A Customer-Centric Experience
Many customers have praised the friendly staff and the clean atmosphere. One patron, Esteban Table, noted, "Workers are nice and friendly. Place is super clean." It's this commitment to service that makes Paisanos not just a pizzeria, but a community hub.
Culinary Creativity
The genius of Paisanos lies in its creativity. Customers often mention the owner’s inventive spirit, resulting in unique offerings like the SCAR—a delicious combination of spinach, grilled chicken, avocado, and ranch. As Luke Jaeger put it, it’s a must-try for any pizza lover. The garlic knot sliders have also received rave reviews, particularly the eggplant option, showcasing their willingness to innovate.
Why Visit Paisanos Pizza?
Whether you're popping in for a quick slice during lunch or settling down for a hearty dinner, Paisanos Pizza (New City) aims to exceed expectations with their robust flavors and friendly service. Plus, if you're lucky, you might just find one of their classic desserts waiting for you in the fridge!
So take a break from your day, and indulge in the delicious offerings at Paisanos Pizza. Their phone number is +1 845-709-6234 for takeout or inquiries—don’t miss out on a true gastronomic experience in New City!

Sauce is good. Crust is crispy. Garlic knots are HUGE! Workers are nice and friendly. Place is super clean. I got absolutely nothing to complain about

The last few times I've ordered, the pizza is very inconsistent... Even on the same order. I nice medium done crust is perfect Regular pie has great flavor. Sauce tastes like the perfect tomato, not to sweet and not to tart. Cheese is just good mozzarella. Nice, clean and new location!

Great little pizza shop, the owner loves to make pizzas and you can often find some of his mad scientist creations in the front window. Always has some sort of classic desert in the fridge, store is always super clean. Great news shop and if you love pizza, gotta come try it. My personal favorite: The SCAR. spinach, chicken (grilled), avocado, ranch.

Came in the other day for a quick slice and was immediately served with a friendly smile from the girl that worked there. The slice was absolutely delicious (I think I got the margarita square?). Clean atmosphere and nice staff, can’t ask for much more! Thank you for a nice lunch

Absolutely delicious! Super cool menu ; I tried one of their garlic knot sliders (went with the eggplant option) was super happy with that choice never saw that on a menu before hope it catches on …

New Spot! great pizza, tasted really good and had loads of toppings. I liked the faint sweetness of the crust and the chicken tasted great. Tried the chicken bacon ranch and the chipotle chicken slice . Amazing

The food is great here and I absolutely love the girl who answers the phone & takes the orders and does deliveries, she is so sweet and kind and the pizza here is really great. The dough smells wonderful and they do a great job with delivering in a timely fashion. Thank you so much Paesanos!

All new items to the menu. All delicious choices. Recommend the rice Balls, paninis, tortilla soup. Pesto is to die for!! Go check out the new items and see for yourself. Best garlic knots in town now!